Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
169 lines (135 loc) · 5.05 KB

CODE_REVIEW.md

File metadata and controls

169 lines (135 loc) · 5.05 KB

Code Review and Improvement Recommendations

Type Safety Issues

High Priority

  1. Loose Type Definitions

    • dbConfig: any in DatabaseAnalysis and QueryInterface components
    • Consider creating proper interface definitions for database configuration
    • Replace all any types with proper type definitions

  2. Incomplete Error Handling

    • Error states in components need proper typing
    • Add comprehensive error boundaries for component failures

Medium Priority

  1. Interface Improvements
    • Consider making common interfaces shared across components
    • Move interfaces to separate type definition files
    • Add proper JSDoc documentation for interfaces

Component Architecture

High Priority

  1. State Management

    • Large state objects in QueryInterface component
    • Consider using React Context or state management library for complex state
    • Break down large components into smaller, more manageable pieces

  2. Component Size

    • QueryInterface.tsx is too large (>1000 lines)
    • Split into smaller, focused components
    • Extract logic into custom hooks

Medium Priority

  1. Props Drilling
    • Configuration being passed through multiple levels
    • Consider using React Context for global configuration
    • Create a configuration provider component

Performance Optimizations

High Priority

  1. Memoization Opportunities

    • Add useMemo for expensive computations
    • Use useCallback for function props
    • Implement React.memo for pure components

  2. Data Fetching

    • Implement proper loading states
    • Add error boundaries for failed requests
    • Consider using SWR or React Query for data fetching

Medium Priority

  1. Render Optimization
    • Optimize re-renders in DatabaseAnalysis component
    • Review and optimize component tree structure
    • Add performance monitoring

Configuration Management

High Priority

  1. Constants and Configurations

    • Move hardcoded values to configuration files
    • Create dedicated config directory for different environments
    • Implement proper configuration validation
    • Examples of values to move:
      • Available LLM models and their configurations
      • API endpoints and specifications
      • UI constants (page sizes, timeouts, etc.)
      • Feature flags

  2. API Compatibility Layer

    • Create adapter layer for OpenAI-compatible APIs
    • Implement provider-agnostic interfaces
    • Add validation for API compatibility
    • Support custom API endpoints that follow OpenAI specification

Medium Priority

  1. Configuration Management
    • Implement configuration hot-reloading
    • Add configuration validation schemas
    • Create configuration documentation
    • Add configuration migration support

Code Organization

High Priority

  1. File Structure

    • Move interfaces to separate type files
    • Create dedicated hooks directory
    • Separate business logic from UI components
    • Create constants directory for shared values
    • Implement proper configuration structure

  2. Code Duplication

    • Extract common utility functions
    • Create shared components for repeated UI elements
    • Implement proper code sharing strategies
    • Create reusable configuration handlers

Medium Priority

  1. Documentation
    • Add comprehensive JSDoc comments
    • Document complex business logic
    • Add README files for each major component
    • Document configuration options and their effects

Security

High Priority

  1. API Key Handling

    • Move sensitive configuration to environment variables
    • Implement proper API key rotation
    • Add input sanitization for user inputs

  2. Database Security

    • Implement query sanitization
    • Add rate limiting
    • Implement proper error handling for failed queries

Testing

High Priority

  1. Unit Tests
    • Add tests for critical components
    • Test error handling scenarios
    • Add integration tests for database operations

Medium Priority

  1. Test Coverage
    • Implement end-to-end tests
    • Add performance testing
    • Add snapshot tests for UI components

Development Experience

Medium Priority

  1. Developer Tools

    • Add proper ESLint rules
    • Implement Prettier for code formatting
    • Add pre-commit hooks for code quality

  2. Build Process

    • Optimize build configuration
    • Add proper development scripts
    • Implement proper CI/CD pipeline

Accessibility

High Priority

  1. ARIA Labels
    • Add proper aria-labels to interactive elements
    • Implement keyboard navigation
    • Add proper focus management

Medium Priority

  1. Color Contrast
    • Ensure proper color contrast ratios
    • Add proper focus indicators
    • Implement proper dark mode support

Next Steps

  1. Address high-priority type safety issues
  2. Implement proper error handling
  3. Break down large components
  4. Add comprehensive testing
  5. Implement security best practices

This document will serve as a reference for ongoing improvements to the codebase. Each item should be addressed based on its priority level and impact on the application.